San Diego Jewish World
                         'There's a Jewish story everywhere'
                                               

 

 Vol. 1, No. 134

       Tuesday Evening, September 11, 2007
 
Community Phone & Email Directory
Jewish World Community Calendar

AJE Makor Calendar

UJF Community Calendar
 
Search This Site
(click here)
Jewish Forum questions: join the discussion;
          
click here
Jewish Grapevine files
Back issues by date
Back-issue headlines
PLEASE SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS; THEY ARE HELPING TO BRING San Diego Jewish World TO YOU:
Agency for Jewish Education
America's Vacation Center 
●Bubbla Packaging
Chabad at University CityCongregation Beth Israel
Elijah's
Humanistic Jewish Congregation
I'm There For You Baby radio show  
In the Know radio show
Israel Guide Dog Center
JCC Maccabi games  
Jewish American Chamber of Commerce 
Jewish Community Foundation
●Jewish Family Service
Museum of Man:
Journey to the copper age
Ohr Shalom Synagogue 
Old Town Trolley Tours of San Diego
San Diego Community Colleges
San Diego Jewish Academy
Seacrest Village Retirement Communities
Tifereth Israel Synagogue
Columnists/
   Writers

*David Amos
*Laurie Baron
*Judy Lash Balint
*Shoshana Bryen
*Cynthia Citron
*Carol Davis
*Rabbi Wayne Dosick
*Garry Fabian
*Gail Forman
*Sandy Golden
*Gerry Greber
.
*Norman & Roberta Greene
*
Alex Grobman,PhD
*
Donald H. Harrison
*
Irvin Jacobs, MD
*
Natasha Josefowitz
*
Bruce Kesler
*Judith Apter Klinghoffer
*
Rabbi Baruch Lederman
*
Dov Burt Levy
*
Elizabeth Levy
*
Ya'acov Liberman
*
Bruce Lowitt
*
Joel Moskowitz, MD
*Joe Naiman
*
Sheila Orysiek

*Yoni Peres
*Fred Reiss
*Michael Rosen
*Rabbi Leonard Rosenthal
*Dan Schaffer
*Ira Sharkansky
*Dorothea Shefer-Vanson
*David Strom
*Lynne Thrope
*Eileen Wingard
*Isaac Yetiv
*Edward Zeiden
*Heather Zeiden
____________
San Diego Jewish World interns
*William Bohannon
*Harry Doshay

 
Contact us
Email: sdheritage@cox.net
PO Box 19363
San Diego, CA 92159
(619) 265-0808

San Diego Jewish World is a publication of The Harrison Enterprises of San Diego, co-owned by Donald & Nancy Harrison.
 


 


San Diego Jewish World by email

Would you like to receive an e-mail each evening with an interactive list of our stories similar to the one below?
 
 Simply e-mail your request to us at
sdheritage@cox.net with the word "subscribe" in the subject line of your message form. 
 
 This service, updating you on Jewish news from around the world, is free, and you may unsubscribe at any time!

 


(Please click on headline below to jump to the story)

Israel and Middle East

Early morning Kassam attack wounds 69 sleeping Israeli soldiers

France's Foreign Minister seeking the release of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit

Sept. 10: Peres meets survivor of Twin Towers attack, who walked down from 78th floor

Excavations uncover Jerusalem's ancient main drainage channel

Beehives dating back to biblical times are discovered in Tel Rehov

Iraq Debate

Levin, chairing Armed Services debate, outlines war failures

Senator Boxer lectures Gen. Petraeus during today's hearing on Iraq War

Cardin skeptical 'surge' tactic works

Feingold says Iraq war diverted attention from Al Qaeda threat


Shoshana Bryen: 9/11 anniversary reminds that in Iraq too, wreckers try to undo builders
 

United States of America

Hadassah demonstrates solidarity with Virginia Tech in pre 9/11 ceremony


Interfaith website will teach curious Muslims about Judaism

ADL urges Jewish institutions to be security conscious over holidays

Features

Jewish Grapevine

News Sleuths

Greater San Diego County

Donald H. Harrison: Judge rules Bennetts are entitled to $12.9 million for Marla's terror murder

Harry Doshay:
AIDS speaker commands student attention at SDJA assembly

Adat Shalom programs geared both to active minds and bodies

Arts & Entertainment


Gail Feinstein Forman: AARON, the art-conceiving and executing computer, on display at Museum of Contemporary Art.

Judge rules Bennetts are entitled to $12.9 million for Marla's terror murder

By Donald H. Harrison

U.S. District Court Judge Royce Lamberth has ruled in Washington D.C. that Michael and Linda Bennett and their daughter Lisa, all of San Diego, are entitled to compensation of $12.9 million in the wrongful death of Marla Bennett.

Bennett, 24, was among  nine people killed July 31, 2002, when a terrorist bomb shattered the Frank Sinatra Cafeteria at Hebrew University.  After her body was brought home, attendance at her funeral was so large that Temple Emanu-El, the Bennett's congregation, conducted the service at neighboring Tifereth Israel Synagogue which has a large combination sanctuary and social hall that accommodated 1,500 people.

In a critical part of the ruling, Lamberth said that Hamas, which claimed responsibility for the attack, is supported by the government of Iran, and that Iran therefore was liable to pay compensation for the wrongful death.

Iran neither acknowledged the authority of the court in the case nor did it participate in the trial, in which the judge issued a default judgment.

Although the Bennetts had known of Lamberth's decision since the end of August, they did not publicize it. Word did not get out until the Jerusalem Post carried a story today by its Washington correspondent, Hillary Leila Krieger.  The Jerusalem Post story in turn was disseminated by Israel's Consulate General in Los Angeles.

Linda Bennett said the judgment was "bittersweet," explaining that if money can ever be collected from Iran, she would like much of it to be used in support of causes that Marla held dear. 

She told San Diego Jewish World that two funds
that had been established in San Diego in Marla's memory would most likely receive such money as is collected: One, the Marla Bennett Memorial Fund  held at the Jewish Community Foundation,  provides emergency assistance to both Jews and non-Jews.  Another, created by Temple Emanu-El, provides grants to youngsters seeking to travel to Israel.

While no amount of money could ever erase the pain of losing her daughter so violently, Bennett said she was glad that the court wants to make the perpetrators "pay." She said that she additionally hopes some of the realized funds can advance peaceful relations between Israelis and Palestinians, a cause in which Marla believed.

Michael Bennett said that he and Linda both traveled to Washington several months ago to testify about Marla's life, interests and "what she meant to people... How she had so many friends, how she worked at her friendships, how much she meant to us."

As Iran did not contest the suit, there was no cross examination.  The Bennetts were represented by Ed Carnot, a former Washington lawyer who returned to his boyhood home of San Diego, where he had known Linda Bennett since they both were in junior high school.
 

Carnot recommended that the Bennetts retain as co-counsel Thomas Fortune Fay, who specializes in cases involving terror victims, and an additional attorney, Ron Karp.  Fay had won a similar judgment for the family of Alisa Flatow, a Brandeis University student who was killed in 1995 when a suicide bomber ran his car into a bus carrying her and others to the Israeli settlement of Kfar Darom in Gaza. Flatow's father, Stephen, has since become a well-known lecturer and spokesperson for the fight against terror.

Fay just last Friday won a $2.65 billion judgment  in Judge Lambreth's court for the families of the victims of the 1983 bombing
of the U.S. Marine Corps barracks in Beirut, Lebanon—an incident that led President Ronald Reagan to withdraw American peacekeeping forces from that country.


Asked if the Bennetts ever would collect any money from Iran, given Iran's non-participation in the case and that country having no formal diplomatic relations with the United States government nor obvious assets in the U.S., the attorney replied he did not wish to answer that question in any detail.  However, he said, "we have some ideas about recovery.  We are hopeful we can collect something."


 

Israel and Middle East

Early morning Kassam attack wounds 69 sleeping Israeli soldiers

KIBBUTZ ZIKKIM, Israel (Staff Report)—Sixty nine Israeli soldiers were wounded when a Kassam rocket launched from near Beit Hanoun in northern Gaza landed at an IDF basic training base near Kibbutz Zikkim in the western Negev at around 1:30 am this morning.

The rocket landed directly on an empty mess tent used in the daytime. Soldiers sleeping in adjacent tents were wounded by shrapnel. One IDF soldier was critically wounded, four seriously wounded, seven moderately wounded and 57 lightly wounded.

The Salah a-Din Brigades - the military arm of the Public Resistance Committees - and the Islamic Jihad both claimed responsibility for the attack. Islamic Jihad operatives celebrated the attack in their mosques in Gaza later Tuesday morning.


Hamas spokesman Fawzi Barhoum, speaking on Hamas radio, praised the rocket attack on an Israeli army base, calling it a "victory from God...We consider this a victory from God for the resistance. We consider the resistance as the legitimate right of the Palestinians to defend themselves and restore their rights."

In response to the attack, Israel's Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told France's visiting Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner today "that alongside Israel’s desire to reach peace, it is necessary to defend its citizens against terrorist attacks and added that Israel would continue its counter-terrorist operations," according to a statement from Olmert's office. "The Prime Minister emphasized that there is no place for talks of any kind with Hamas, which cannot be a partner in the peace process since its path is that of terrorism.

Israel's Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni responded to the attack during her a joint news conference  with Kouchner.

"
This morning began with a deliberate attack on Israel from the Gaza Strip. We discussed the situation in the Gaza Strip and its comparison to the different situation in the West Bank," she said.

"When it comes to the Israeli policy, of course, and I believe that this also is and should be international policy, we need to act with a clear distinction between the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, between moderates and extremists, between Abu Mazen-Fayyad and those in Gaza who are looking not to create a state of their own but to act against the existence of the State of Israel.

"The policy is going to be totally different when it comes to the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. So on one hand we need to act against the terrorists in Gaza Strip; on the other hand we need to take this opportunity to reach an understanding and find the common ground between Israel and the moderate, pragmatic leaders, namely Abu Mazen and Salam Fayyad."

Asked by a reporter if Israel would respond militarily to this latest incident, Livni responded:

"
It doesn't make any difference to me exactly which terrorist organization claimed responsibility for the attack. All of Gaza is controlled by Hamas. They have the ability to stop the attacks and decided not to do so. So our policy towards them has to be radically different.

"True, in the context of this differential policy, the dialogue with Abu Mazen, which I do consider very important, will not provide a short-term solution to the situation in Gaza. I hope it creates such a solution, that it can improve the situation in the long run, so in the meantime Israel must take deliberate action. I think we have the means, and not only military means, that can be used against what is happening in Gaza. But here as well, the truth is that even if these measures will not stop the rocket launchings, because we are talking about a group of leaders that doesn’t care about their people and are not affected by deterrence, and who are motivated by extremist-religious Islamic ideology that has one goal - despite all this, I say that we are obliged to take action, because there are things a state has to do both to reduce the Kassam rocket fire and to make it clear that matters cannot continue in this way.

"We left Gaza with the goal of ending Israeli responsibility for what is taking place there. All the processes were also meant to achieve a situation of ending the “occupation” – in international terms, and an end to Israeli responsibility. So, I think that Israel’s legal position and our ability to use the means at our disposal are better than in the past. Of course, this needs to be restrained and based on clear criteria. Meetings have been scheduled on this matter for next week, and I am taking part in these discussions on behalf of the Foreign Ministry."

Concerning whether Israel might retaliate, Kouchner told the news conference: "
I understand that Israel has to defend its population and there is a contract between the government and the army, first to defend the Israeli population. I don’t know how they will react or not. But certainly the major goal should be not to undermine the process of negotiation with Abu Mazen and the West Bank..."

Israel's Defense Force, meanwhile, provided on its website some details of the rocket attack and its aftermath.

"After receiving treatment on location, the soldiers were rushed to the hospital in Medical Corps ambulances assisted by the Air Force and Magen David Adom," the statement said.

"The attack occurred diring the night but medical treatment was administered very early on.  In a matter of minutes first response teams of the IDF assisted by Magen David Adom medics and paramedics arrived at the scene and began administrating treatment to the injured soldiers," explained the commander of the Southern Command medical corps, Colonel Dr. Carmi Bartel.

The statement added that "the soldiers were transferred to the Barzilay hospital in Ashkelon, the Soroka hospital in Beersheba, the Shiba hospital in Tel Hashomer, Belinson in Petach Tikva and Haddassah Ein-Kerem in Jerusalem. Thirty eight of the soldiers were released after being checked by doctors in the hospital.

"Shortly following the incident, the Chief Engineer, Brigadier General Moshe Sheli and the Commander of the "Magal" combat unit, Colonel Eldad Peled arrived at the Zikim base to oversee the medical treatment of the injured soldiers.  In the early morning hours the GOC of the Southern Command, Major General Yoav Galant and the Commander of the Ground Corps Major General Benny Ganz met with the base staff in order to receive a briefing on what had happened during the attack as well as to speak to soldiers on base.

"Commanders of the Zikim base also met with soldiers to speak to them about the attack.  The soldiers of the base completed their basic training today and were released to their homes to celebrate Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, with their families."

The preceding utilized materials provided by the offices of Prime Minister Olmert, Foreign Minister Livni and the IDF.
 



France's Foreign Minister seeking the release of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit

JERUSALEM (Press Release)—At a joint news conference with Israel's Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, France's Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner was asked about his efforts in behalf of captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit, who is being held in Gaza. 

Here is transcript of the question and answer:

Question: Mr. Kouchner, I understand during this visit you are meeting with Noam Shalit, the father of Gilad Shalit. I am just curious to know, what sort of involvement does the French government have, if anything, in regard to securing the release of Gilad Shalit, given that he is a French citizen? And also I noticed last night in Ramallah you said, “At the moment the French are not willing to talk to Hamas,” stressing the phrase “at the moment.” When would be the right and appropriate time? 

FM Bernard Kouchner: Yes, I understand your question. We did our best. We were talking about Gilad Shalit every time to all our interlocutors. We tried to learn about him and protect him, etc. In a way it was easier, you are right, because we were able to go Gaza and talk to the people there. Now it is of course difficult at the same time to respect that sort of embargo - “Don’t talk to Hamas” and still get some news. But we have some other means or some other ways, through our Egyptian friends, our NGOs, the Red Cross or all the agencies, and we’ll do it. I just received a letter one hour ago from the families of the prisoners. Of course I received them in Paris. We are all doing our utmost effort to help them and we will follow such a line. But I have no more to say, unfortunately. I do have an appointment this afternoon with the father of Gilad Shalit.

The preceding was provided by Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs
 


 

The Peres Diary

Sept. 10: Peres meets survivor of Twin Towers attack, who walked down from 78th flooor

JERUSALEM (Press Release)—The President of Israel, Mr. Shimon Peres, met in his office with a survivor of the terrorist attack on the Twin Towers in New York on September 11th. He is an Israeli, Israel Czaczkes, who has been living in the U.S.A. for many years.

Czaczkes, who worked at the maintenance engineer of the building, was on the 78th floor.  When the tower was attacked, Czaczkes, aged 68, showed

initiative and walked down the steps of the 78 floors.  The moment he left the building, it collapsed.

The office of Israel's President Shimon from time to time releases accounts of his official activities. We have been publishing them as they are made available.